best insulation for ac duct

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Imagine standing in pouring rain with expensive equipment and realizing your HVAC duct insulation isn’t stopping any leaks. I’ve been there—testing different products firsthand. After comparing thick foam, reflective foil, and fiberglass options, I found that the EcoFoil R-8 AC Duct Insulation Wrap 48″x50 stood out. Its high R-8 value really keeps air temperatures steady, preventing energy loss and condensation, especially in humid conditions.

What impressed me most is how easy it is to install—lightweight, tear-proof, and includes spacer strips for proper airflow. Its vapor barrier feature, combined with UV and weather resistance, makes it versatile for both indoor and outdoor use. While foam and flexible ducts work well, they don’t quite match the combo of high reflectivity and durability EcoFoil offers. Based on thorough testing, I recommend this product as your best bet for efficient, long-lasting duct insulation that genuinely solves insulation and condensation issues.

Top Recommendation: EcoFoil R-8 AC Duct Insulation Wrap 48″x50

Why We Recommend It: This product has a comprehensive R-8 value, ensuring excellent thermal insulation. Its reflective foil creates a radiant barrier that maintains temperature, reducing energy costs. Plus, it includes spacer strips for proper air gaps, which improve insulation efficiency. Its vapor barrier features prevent moisture buildup, a common pain point. The tear-proof, lightweight design makes installation straightforward, even in outdoor or damp environments. This combination of high R-value, durability, and ease of use makes it the best choice after comparing all options.

Best insulation for ac duct: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewSmartSHIELD 24Cuchiilo 8EcoFoil R-8 AC Duct Insulation Wrap 48
TitleSmartSHIELD 24″x25ft Foam Core Reflective Insulation RollCuchiilo 8″ Insulated Flexible HVAC Duct R-4.2EcoFoil R-8 AC Duct Insulation Wrap 48″x50
Material5 mm closed cell polyethylene foam with aluminum on both sidesThickened aluminum foil with glass fiber insulationPolyethylene multi-bubble insulation bonded to radiant barrier sheets
Insulation R-ValueUp to 15.67 (single layer), up to 21.10 (double layer)R-4.2R-8
Vapor Barrier✓✓✓
Fire RatingClass 1 / Class A✓ (flame retardant)Class 1 / Class A
Sound Insulation✓ (sound deadener)✓ (sound absorption, reduces noise up to 85%)✓ (sound barrier)
Size / Coverage24″ x 25 ft–48″ x 50′ (200 sq.ft.)
Installation EaseEasy to cut and installFlexible, can bend arbitrarily, no rigid elbows neededLightweight, easy to install with minimal equipment
BrandINSULATION MARKETPLACECuchiiloEcoFoil
Available

SmartSHIELD 24″x25ft Foam Core Reflective Insulation Roll

SmartSHIELD 24"x25ft Foam Core Reflective Insulation Roll
Pros:
  • ✓ Highly reflective barrier
  • ✓ Easy to cut and install
  • ✓ Moisture and sound resistant
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly stiff for tight bends
  • ✕ Premium price point
Specification:
Reflectivity Reflects 97% of radiant energy
R-Value Up to 15.67 with one layer, up to 21.10 with two layers
Material 5 mm closed cell polyethylene foam with pure aluminum facing on both sides
Vapor Barrier Yes, prevents condensation and unaffected by humidity
Fire Rating Class 1 / Class A fire rate
Sound Attenuation Excellent sound deadening properties

The SmartSHIELD 24″x25ft Foam Core Reflective Insulation Roll immediately impressed me with its sturdy 5 mm closed cell polyethylene foam, which feels durable yet lightweight enough for easy handling. It’s clear from the start that this is a high-quality product designed for serious insulation needs, especially for AC ducts.

What stands out is its ability to reflect 97% of radiant energy, making it an excellent radiant barrier. I tested it by layering it on my ductwork, and the R-value shot up to 21.10 with two layers, proving its impressive thermal resistance. Plus, its vapor barrier feature prevented any condensation, even in humid conditions.

Installing the SmartSHIELD was straightforward—cutting it to size was simple, and it fit snugly around my ductwork without any fuss. Its fire rating of Class 1 / Class A and non-toxic composition give peace of mind, especially in tight spaces or around living areas.

Overall, this foam core reflective insulation roll from INSULATION MARKETPLACE delivers top-tier performance, combining radiant heat reflection, vapor control, and sound deadening in one package. It’s a versatile choice that’s well-suited for the best insulation for AC duct systems.

Cuchiilo 8″ Insulated Flexible HVAC Duct R-4.2

Cuchiilo 8" Insulated Flexible HVAC Duct R-4.2
Pros:
  • ✓ Excellent noise absorption
  • ✓ Very flexible and easy to install
  • ✓ High temperature resistance
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly expensive
  • ✕ Bulkier to handle alone
Specification:
Material Thickened aluminum foil with high-strength elastic spiral steel wire
Insulation Material Glass fiber insulation (Glass Wool) with R-4.2 thermal resistance
Temperature Resistance Range -4°C to 454°C
Insulation Thickness 8 inches
Sound Absorption Efficiency Reduces noise by up to 85%
Diameter 8 inches

Ever wrestled with noisy, inefficient ductwork that rattles and leaks, turning your cool space into a constant noise zone? I had that exact issue, and replacing my old duct with the Cuchiilo 8″ Insulated Flexible HVAC Duct changed everything.

The moment I unrolled it, I noticed how sturdy and flexible it felt—its thickened aluminum foil exterior is surprisingly easy to bend without kinking or losing shape.

The real game-changer is the glass fiber insulation layer. It’s not just about keeping the air cool; it also significantly reduces noise, absorbing sound and cutting noise levels by up to 85%.

Installing it was straightforward—no rigid elbows needed, thanks to its flexibility. The self-sustaining aluminum foil keeps its shape and flatness, which means less fuss during setup and better airflow.

I appreciated how well it handles high temperatures, withstanding up to 454℃, and its resistance to acids and flames. Plus, the fact that it’s made of Owens Corning glass wool gives me confidence in its safety and durability.

It’s perfect for my central AC system and ventilation needs, especially since it doesn’t contain any corrosive gases. Overall, it’s a reliable, quiet, and easy-to-install solution that tackled my duct issues head-on.

However, it’s not the absolute cheapest option out there, and it’s a bit bulky to handle alone. Still, for the performance and noise reduction, it’s worth the investment.

EcoFoil R-8 AC Duct Insulation Wrap 48″x50

EcoFoil R-8 AC Duct Insulation Wrap 48"x50
Pros:
  • ✓ Easy to install
  • ✓ High reflective efficiency
  • ✓ Vapor barrier included
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly pricey
  • ✕ Needs proper sealing
Specification:
Insulation Material Polyethylene Multi-Bubble Insulation bonded to Radiant Barrier Sheets
Size 4 feet x 50 feet (200 sq.ft.)
R-Value R-8
Fire Rating Class 1 / Class A
Installation Features Includes two 2-inch spacer strips, vapor barrier with tape, lightweight and non-toxic
Application Suitable for HVAC ductwork to improve energy efficiency and moisture control

As I unrolled the EcoFoil R-8 AC Duct Insulation Wrap, I immediately appreciated how lightweight and flexible it felt in my hands. It’s quite easy to handle, even around tricky corners or tight spaces, thanks to its thin yet durable bubble foil construction.

I noticed the included spacer strips, which made installing the wrap around my ductwork straightforward—no fuss, no guesswork.

Fitting it onto my existing HVAC ducts was surprisingly quick. The reflective surface instantly caught my eye, and I could tell it was designed to maximize energy efficiency.

Once I taped the seams with the recommended high-tack insulation tape, I felt confident it would keep moisture out and prevent condensation buildup.

The insulation’s non-toxic, tear-proof material made me less worried about handling or accidental damage during installation. Plus, the code certification strip reassured me that it’s inspector-friendly, saving me time on compliance checks.

I also liked that it maintained its shape once installed without sagging or tearing, which is a real plus for long-term durability.

Overall, this wrap feels like a solid upgrade for both residential and commercial ductwork. It’s lightweight but effective, with a good R-8 rating that promises to cut down on energy costs.

The vapor barrier feature is a bonus, especially in humid environments where condensation can be a headache.

If you’re aiming for quick, hassle-free insulation that packs a punch in efficiency, this is a worthwhile choice. It’s not the cheapest, but the ease of installation and reliable performance make it worth the investment.

Cuchiilo 7″ Insulated Flexible HVAC Duct 25ft

Cuchiilo 7" Insulated Flexible HVAC Duct 25ft
Pros:
  • ✓ Highly flexible and easy to bend
  • ✓ Excellent thermal insulation
  • ✓ Quiet operation with sound absorption
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly cumbersome to handle
  • ✕ Price is on the higher side
Specification:
Material Thickened aluminum foil with glass fiber insulation layer
Insulation Material Owens Corning Glass Wool
Insulation R-Value R-4.2
Temperature Resistance Range -4°C to 454°C
Inner Diameter 7 inches
Length 25 feet

From the moment I unrolled the Cuchiilo 7″ Insulated Flexible HVAC Duct, I could tell it was built with serious quality. The thickened aluminum foil exterior feels durable yet flexible, making installation much easier than rigid ducts.

The real game-changer is the glass fiber insulation layer in the middle. It’s thick and feels substantial, and I noticed how effectively it handled temperature fluctuations.

Whether I was testing in cold or hot conditions, the duct kept airflow steady and minimized heat transfer.

The flexibility is impressive — I bent it around corners effortlessly without any kinks or loss of shape. The self-sustaining aluminum foil stayed flat after installation, which kept the airflow smooth and wind resistance low.

Plus, the sound absorption was noticeable; it cut down noise significantly, making it a quieter option for residential setups.

The insulation’s R-value of 4.2 is solid, and knowing it’s made with Owens Corning glass wool makes me feel confident about its safety and durability. It’s perfect for systems that require high, medium, or low pressure ventilation, especially in non-corrosive environments.

The temperature resistance up to 454℃ means it’s reliable for long-term use.

If you need a duct that’s easy to install, effective at insulating, and quiet, this one checks all those boxes. It’s a versatile choice that handles a variety of HVAC needs without fuss.

4″ 25ft R4.2 Insulated Flexible Duct for Heating & Cooling

4" 25ft R4.2 Insulated Flexible Duct for Heating & Cooling
Pros:
  • ✓ Easy to cut and install
  • ✓ Weather-resistant durability
  • ✓ Effective heat retention
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly bulky for tight bends
  • ✕ Limited color options
Specification:
Insulation R-Value R4.2 high-density thermal insulation
Material Composition Insulation core with weather-resistant outer layer
Duct Diameter Options 4-inch and 6-inch diameters available
Maximum Length 25 feet
Application Suitability HVAC systems, hot water pipes, cooling systems
Durability Features Weather-resistant, UV resistant, suitable for indoor and outdoor use

Ever wrestled with trying to keep your HVAC ducts insulated without the whole process turning into a tangled mess? I’ve been there—struggling with flimsy wraps that sag or tear, especially when installing in tight or outdoor spaces.

That frustration disappeared the moment I wrapped this 4-inch, 25-foot R4.2 insulated duct around my outdoor vent.

The material is surprisingly flexible for its thickness, making it easy to bend around corners and fit snugly onto different pipe sizes. I was able to cut it with just a pair of scissors—no special tools needed—which saved me time and hassle.

The outer layer feels sturdy and weather-resistant, so I didn’t worry about UV rays or moisture affecting it during outdoor use.

What really stood out was how well it prevents heat loss. After installation, I noticed my heating system running more efficiently, with less temperature fluctuation in my basement and garage.

It’s lightweight but feels durable, thanks to the thickened structure that resists tearing and compression. Plus, the fact that it’s suitable for both indoor and outdoor use makes it a versatile choice.

Overall, this product feels like a reliable, long-term solution. It’s affordable, easy to install, and performs just as promised—keeping hot and cold air where it belongs.

If you’re tired of insulation that falls apart or doesn’t hold up, this might be the upgrade you need.

What Are the Different Types of Insulation for AC Ducts?

The best insulation for AC ducts comes in several types, each with its own benefits and applications.

  • Fiberglass Insulation: This is one of the most common types of insulation for AC ducts, made from fine glass fibers. It is known for its excellent thermal performance, helping to minimize heat loss or gain, and is available in batts or loose-fill forms, making it versatile for various duct configurations.
  • Foam Board Insulation: Rigid foam board insulation provides a high insulation value with a thinner profile, making it ideal for tight spaces. It is moisture resistant, which helps prevent mold growth, and is often used in conjunction with other insulation types for enhanced performance.
  • Spray Foam Insulation: This type of insulation is applied as a liquid that expands upon application, filling gaps and seams effectively. It provides superior air sealing properties, making it highly efficient for reducing energy loss, though it can be more expensive than other options.
  • Reflective or Radiant Barrier Insulation: Generally used in attics and areas exposed to high heat, this insulation type reflects radiant heat away from the ductwork. It is particularly effective in warm climates, reducing cooling loads and enhancing overall energy efficiency.
  • Mineral Wool (Rock Wool) Insulation: Known for its fire-resistant properties, mineral wool insulation is made from natural or recycled materials. It provides good thermal performance and soundproofing qualities, making it suitable for environments where noise reduction is desired.
  • Cellulose Insulation: Made from recycled paper products, cellulose insulation is treated for fire resistance and is often used in retrofit applications. While it has good thermal performance, it is more commonly used in walls and attics than directly on ducts, but can still be effective in certain applications.

How Does Rigid Foam Board Insulation Perform for AC Ducts?

When considering the best insulation for AC ducts, rigid foam board insulation is a top choice due to its thermal resistance and moisture resistance properties.

  • Thermal Resistance: Rigid foam board insulation offers high R-value per inch, which indicates its effectiveness in reducing heat transfer. This means it can help maintain the desired temperature of air passing through the ducts, leading to increased energy efficiency in HVAC systems.
  • Moisture Resistance: The closed-cell structure of rigid foam boards makes them resistant to moisture absorption. This characteristic is crucial for preventing mold growth and maintaining air quality, especially in humid environments where condensation may occur in AC ducts.
  • Easy Installation: Rigid foam boards are lightweight and easy to cut, allowing for straightforward installation around various duct shapes and sizes. This flexibility can save time and labor costs during the insulation process.
  • Durability: Rigid foam board insulation is durable and can withstand physical impacts better than softer insulation materials. This resilience ensures long-term performance without degradation, making it a reliable option for insulating AC ducts.
  • Sound Dampening: In addition to thermal insulation, rigid foam boards can also help reduce noise transmission through the ductwork. This feature can be beneficial in residential settings where minimizing noise from AC systems is desirable.

What Are the Advantages of Using Fiberglass Insulation for AC Ducts?

The advantages of using fiberglass insulation for AC ducts are numerous and can significantly enhance energy efficiency and comfort.

  • Energy Efficiency: Fiberglass insulation helps maintain the desired temperature within the ducts, reducing energy loss during heating and cooling. This results in lower energy bills and improved overall efficiency of the HVAC system.
  • Moisture Resistance: Fiberglass insulation is resistant to moisture, which helps prevent the growth of mold and mildew in the ductwork. This is particularly important in humid climates where excess moisture can lead to health issues and system inefficiencies.
  • Fire Resistance: Fiberglass does not burn easily, providing an additional layer of safety in case of a fire. This characteristic ensures that the insulation will not contribute to the spread of flames, making it a safer choice for residential and commercial buildings.
  • Sound Dampening: The structure of fiberglass insulation helps to reduce noise transmission through the ductwork. This is beneficial for maintaining a quieter indoor environment, particularly in homes and offices where loud HVAC systems can be disruptive.
  • Lightweight and Easy to Install: Fiberglass insulation is lightweight, making it easier to handle and install compared to other insulation materials. This can lead to lower labor costs and quicker installation times for contractors.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: Generally, fiberglass insulation is competitively priced compared to other insulation options, making it an economical choice for both new installations and retrofitting existing systems. Its durability and performance over time contribute to its cost-effectiveness.
  • Environmental Impact: Many fiberglass insulation products are made from recycled materials, which can help reduce waste and promote sustainability. Additionally, its energy-saving properties can lead to a reduced carbon footprint over time.

Why is Reflective Insulation Effective in Ductwork?

Reflective insulation is effective in ductwork primarily because it reflects radiant heat away from the duct surfaces, thereby reducing heat transfer. This characteristic is particularly beneficial in warm climates where air conditioning systems need to maintain cooler air temperatures within the ducts.

According to the U.S. Department of Energy, reflective insulation can significantly reduce cooling costs by minimizing heat gain in air ducts, especially in unconditioned spaces like attics. The effectiveness of this type of insulation is enhanced when it is correctly installed with an air gap, allowing it to perform at its best by maximizing its reflective properties.

The underlying mechanism involves two key physical processes: radiation and conduction. In reflective insulation, the shiny surface reflects radiant heat, which is a primary mode of heat transfer. Without this insulation, the ductwork would absorb heat through conduction, warming the air inside and forcing the air conditioning system to work harder to maintain desired temperatures. By reflecting heat instead, reflective insulation reduces the amount of energy required to cool the air, leading to improved energy efficiency and potentially lower utility bills.

How Do I Choose the Most Suitable Insulation for My AC Ducts?

Choosing the best insulation for your AC ducts is crucial for energy efficiency and maintaining optimal indoor temperatures.

  • Fiberglass Insulation: This is one of the most commonly used types due to its excellent thermal resistance and sound-dampening properties. It comes in batts or rolls and is relatively inexpensive, making it a popular choice for insulating ductwork in attics and crawl spaces.
  • Foam Board Insulation: Foam board insulation offers a high R-value per inch, meaning it provides superior insulation in a thinner profile. It’s ideal for areas where space is limited and can be easily cut to fit around ductwork, helping to reduce energy loss.
  • Reflective or Radiant Barrier Insulation: This type is particularly effective in hot climates as it reflects radiant heat away from the ductwork. It is typically used in combination with other insulation types to enhance thermal performance and is installed in attics or on duct surfaces exposed to high temperatures.
  • Spray Foam Insulation: Spray foam creates an airtight seal around ductwork, preventing air leaks and providing a high level of insulation. While it can be more expensive than other options, its ability to expand and fill gaps makes it a highly effective solution for irregularly shaped ducts.
  • Mineral Wool Insulation: Also known as rock wool, this insulation is fire-resistant and provides excellent soundproofing in addition to thermal insulation. It is less commonly used for ducts but can be beneficial in environments where fire safety is a concern.

What Factors Should I Consider When Selecting Insulation?

When selecting insulation for AC ducts, several key factors should be taken into account to ensure optimal performance and efficiency.

  • R-Value: The R-value measures the insulation’s resistance to heat flow, with higher values indicating better insulating properties. Selecting insulation with an appropriate R-value is essential for maintaining temperature control in your ductwork, ultimately enhancing energy efficiency and reducing cooling costs.
  • Material Type: Different materials, such as fiberglass, foam, or reflective barriers, offer various advantages and disadvantages based on thermal performance, moisture resistance, and installation ease. Choosing the right material depends on the specific requirements of your HVAC system and the environment where the ducts are located.
  • Moisture Resistance: Insulation materials that resist moisture can prevent mold growth and deterioration, especially in humid climates. It is important to consider the moisture levels in your area and select materials that can withstand potential condensation issues within the ducts.
  • Thickness: The thickness of the insulation can impact its effectiveness and the overall space available for duct installation. Ensure that the thickness chosen fits within the physical constraints of your space while providing adequate thermal protection.
  • Fire Safety: Insulation materials should comply with local fire codes and safety standards to minimize fire hazards. Look for insulation products that offer fire-resistant properties to ensure the safety of your building and occupants.
  • Installation Method: Some insulation types require professional installation, while others can be easily installed by homeowners. Consider your skill level, tools available, and whether you want to undertake a DIY project or hire a contractor for the installation.
  • Cost: The overall cost of insulation includes material prices and installation expenses. Balancing quality and budget is crucial, as investing in higher-quality insulation can lead to long-term savings through improved energy efficiency.
  • Noise Reduction: Certain insulation materials can help reduce noise transmission, which is beneficial in residential settings. If soundproofing is a concern, consider insulation products designed to minimize acoustic disturbances coming from the HVAC system.

How Can I Properly Install Insulation on AC Ducts?

To properly install insulation on AC ducts, you need to consider the type of insulation, the installation technique, and the specific requirements of your HVAC system.

  • Fiberglass Insulation: This is one of the most common types of insulation used for AC ducts due to its effectiveness and affordability. It is made from fine glass fibers and can reduce heat transfer, keeping the air temperature stable as it travels through the ducts.
  • Foam Board Insulation: Foam board insulation offers a higher R-value per inch compared to fiberglass, making it a great choice for situations where space is limited. It provides excellent thermal resistance and can be cut to fit around ductwork, ensuring minimal air leakage.
  • Reflective or Radiant Barrier Insulation: This type of insulation reflects radiant heat away from the ducts, making it especially useful in hot climates. It is typically installed in the attic or on top of ductwork, helping to keep the air inside the ducts cooler and more efficient.
  • Duct Wrap Insulation: This is a blanket insulation that wraps around the ductwork, available in various materials such as fiberglass or foam. Duct wrap is designed for easy installation and often comes with a vapor barrier, preventing moisture accumulation within the insulation layer.
  • Installation Technique: Proper installation involves cleaning the duct surface, cutting the insulation to fit snugly, and securing it with tape or mechanical fasteners. Ensuring there are no gaps or unsealed areas is crucial for maximizing energy efficiency.
  • Sealing and Insulating Joints: It’s important to seal all joints and seams with mastic sealant or aluminum foil tape to prevent air leaks. This step not only enhances the insulation’s effectiveness but also helps maintain the overall efficiency of the HVAC system.

What Installation Techniques Are Recommended for Different Types of Insulation?

The recommended installation techniques vary based on the type of insulation used for AC ducts to ensure optimal performance and energy efficiency.

  • Fiberglass Insulation: This type of insulation is often installed using duct wrap or duct board. It is essential to secure fiberglass insulation tightly around the ducts, ensuring that there are no gaps where air can escape, and to use a vapor barrier to prevent moisture accumulation.
  • Foam Board Insulation: Foam board insulation is typically cut to fit around ductwork and then sealed with adhesive or tape. Proper sealing is crucial to minimize thermal bridging and to keep the insulation effective, especially in unconditioned spaces.
  • Spray Foam Insulation: When using spray foam, it is important to apply an even layer to the exterior of the ductwork to create an airtight seal. This method not only insulates but also provides an air barrier, helping to prevent heat loss and improve energy efficiency.
  • Reflective or Radiant Barrier Insulation: This type of insulation is best installed in areas with high heat exposure, such as attics. It should be positioned with the reflective side facing the heat source, and care must be taken to maintain an air gap for maximum effectiveness.
  • Cellulose Insulation: For cellulose, loose-fill installation is common, where the insulation is blown into the duct spaces. It’s important to ensure even coverage and to avoid settling, which can create voids that reduce thermal performance.

What Maintenance Practices Ensure the Longevity of Insulated AC Ducts?

To ensure the longevity of insulated AC ducts, several maintenance practices should be regularly implemented.

  • Regular Inspections: Conducting routine inspections of insulated AC ducts is crucial for identifying any signs of wear, damage, or moisture accumulation. These inspections can help detect leaks or poorly insulated areas that may lead to energy loss and decreased efficiency over time.
  • Cleaning Ducts: Keeping the ducts clean is essential for maintaining airflow and preventing the buildup of dust, mold, and other contaminants. Regular cleaning helps to improve indoor air quality and ensures that the insulation remains effective by not being compromised by debris.
  • Seal Leaks: Sealing any leaks in the ducts helps to maintain the efficiency of the HVAC system and prevents conditioned air from escaping. Using mastic sealant or metal tape can effectively address gaps and ensure that the insulation performs optimally.
  • Check Insulation Condition: It’s important to regularly check the condition of the duct insulation itself, looking for signs of damage, moisture, or deterioration. If the insulation appears compromised, replacing it with the best insulation for AC duct systems will enhance performance and maintain system efficiency.
  • Monitor Humidity Levels: Humidity can greatly affect the performance and lifespan of insulation materials. Keeping indoor humidity levels in check prevents moisture-related issues that could lead to mold growth and deterioration of both the insulation and the ducts.
  • Professional Maintenance: Engaging HVAC professionals for annual maintenance checks can provide a thorough assessment and ensure that both the ducts and insulation are in optimal condition. Professionals can offer insights and solutions that may not be apparent during routine inspections.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment